winter classic [Mafia] Some Spice and Nothing Nice - Game over [Mafia win]

[Blue Jay 22]

8 minutes ago, SnakeDoctor said:

I apologize for my delayed reply 

please help…

[PeteyBOI]

Max Brown (6) – MacDougall, Time Lord, Funnygirl555, KZA, dallsbeep, Zfetch
Lewitelli (5)- J-23, Naslund, luckylager, Lewitelli [Locked], Max Brown
J-23 (5) – Master Radishes, DaBackpack, Dankmemes187, Blue Jay 22
Snake Doctor (3) – Albert, iambrad, Alison
Zfetch (1) - 112
Albert (1) – Snake Doctor

[SV.]

We got some VCs?

[Funnygurl555]

ok so qwags joke voted nik, (seriously?) voted for zfetch, and then made that reads list out of thin air somehow

 

that's rand%

[Naslund]

5 minutes ago, KZA said:

Does anyone recall Z and NIK Interacting at all 

 

Honest question 

We interacted first round. He wall all concerned cause I was sus him

 

[DaBackpack]

ngl I think you are all taking that CFD too seriously. there is no real reading of EoD2 that makes any sense from a "rational actors" perspective. 

 

i'm guessing that the fog of war played into it, but more importantly: if the wolves thought that Max Brown was going to die, they would want at least wolf on that wagon in order to save face.

 

Do you think zfetch KNEW that his vote would be the one that killed Max Brown? With just minutes left? Did WOLVES know that it was possible to SAVE Max Brown given the circumstances? 

 

Wolves would have been talking in wolf-chat, all screaming at each other trying to decide what to do at the LITERAL LAST MINUTE of the phase. They most likely decided, in that last minute, that "Max Brown is a lost cause, let's cut our losses" and stuck zfetch on there in order to save face. 

 

Because here you guys are, right now, basically lock-clearing zfetch for *exactly that reason.* For all intents and purposes, their plan worked. Even if they lost Max Brown in the process, who was dead weight anyway. 

[PeteyBOI]

7 minutes ago, KZA said:

Does anyone recall Z and NIK Interacting at all 

 

Honest question 

no... but nik has interacted with like 5-6 peopl max this game

[iambrad]

2 minutes ago, DaBackpack said:

ngl I think you are all taking that CFD too seriously. there is no real reading of EoD2 that makes any sense from a "rational actors" perspective. 

 

i'm guessing that the fog of war played into it, but more importantly: if the wolves thought that Max Brown was going to die, they would want at least wolf on that wagon in order to save face.

 

Do you think zfetch KNEW that his vote would be the one that killed Max Brown? With just minutes left? Did WOLVES know that it was possible to SAVE Max Brown given the circumstances? 

 

Wolves would have been talking in wolf-chat, all screaming at each other trying to decide what to do at the LITERAL LAST MINUTE of the phase. They most likely decided, in that last minute, that "Max Brown is a lost cause, let's cut our losses" and stuck zfetch on there in order to save face. 

 

Because here you guys are, right now, basically lock-clearing zfetch for *exactly that reason.* For all intents and purposes, their plan worked. Even if they lost Max Brown in the process, who was dead weight anyway. 

did they know though? he voted within the last 5 minutes of eod. that's pretty hard to predict 

[PeteyBOI]

2 minutes ago, DaBackpack said:

ngl I think you are all taking that CFD too seriously. there is no real reading of EoD2 that makes any sense from a "rational actors" perspective. 

 

i'm guessing that the fog of war played into it, but more importantly: if the wolves thought that Max Brown was going to die, they would want at least wolf on that wagon in order to save face.

 

Do you think zfetch KNEW that his vote would be the one that killed Max Brown? With just minutes left? Did WOLVES know that it was possible to SAVE Max Brown given the circumstances? 

 

Wolves would have been talking in wolf-chat, all screaming at each other trying to decide what to do at the LITERAL LAST MINUTE of the phase. They most likely decided, in that last minute, that "Max Brown is a lost cause, let's cut our losses" and stuck zfetch on there in order to save face. 

 

Because here you guys are, right now, basically lock-clearing zfetch for *exactly that reason.* For all intents and purposes, their plan worked. Even if they lost Max Brown in the process, who was dead weight anyway. 

dude... this reads trying waytoo hard... they had anyone other max brown to choose... look who you vioted for that round... J23...

[Funnygurl555]

2 minutes ago, DaBackpack said:

ngl I think you are all taking that CFD too seriously. there is no real reading of EoD2 that makes any sense from a "rational actors" perspective. 

 

i'm guessing that the fog of war played into it, but more importantly: if the wolves thought that Max Brown was going to die, they would want at least wolf on that wagon in order to save face.

 

Do you think zfetch KNEW that his vote would be the one that killed Max Brown? With just minutes left? Did WOLVES know that it was possible to SAVE Max Brown given the circumstances? 

 

Wolves would have been talking in wolf-chat, all screaming at each other trying to decide what to do at the LITERAL LAST MINUTE of the phase. They most likely decided, in that last minute, that "Max Brown is a lost cause, let's cut our losses" and stuck zfetch on there in order to save face. 

 

Because here you guys are, right now, basically lock-clearing zfetch for *exactly that reason.* For all intents and purposes, their plan worked. Even if they lost Max Brown in the process, who was dead weight anyway. 

 

you think the wolves coordinated like that over 5 minutes? do you think their sole incentive would be to lock-clear zfetch? what do you think then about the people who got the max brown wagon going? (e.g., tl, mac)

[luckylager]

We can cfd NIK but I wanna see Z flip here 

[DaBackpack]

This shit happens in CFDs all the time. You can't lock clear a player who, by almost all accounts, was wolfy as shit until he placed his vote somewhere that ENDED UP HAPPENING to lynch a red. If he knew with certainty that his vote swap wasn't needed, he wouldn't have done it. I've done the same thing before as a wolf. It happens. 

 

 

[DumbassTurtle]

2(Qwags) Zfetch, TimeLord 
4(ZFetch) Qwags, LuckyLager, DaBackpack, Kza
3(SnakeDoctor) MacDougal, Alison, DumbassTurtle,  
5(DaBackpack) Dallsbeep, FunnyGurl, iambrad, DankMemes187, Blue Jay
2(Naslund) Porscha 
1(Dankmemes187) Naslund

 

might need double checking

[luckylager]

40 minutes ago, Time Lord said:

We have a good track record of going after slanking scummy players so far 

We do?

[Naslund]

On 12/3/2023 at 9:15 AM, Naslund said:

 

 

 

 

 

Continue on

Here @KZA click the post youll see why i didnt like him at first

Then I got distracted by lewi and now we're here

[Time Lord]

Agree with DBP there except I don't think it needed to be coordinated in the mafia PM, any active scum could read the situation and toss a vote on Max 

[Time Lord]

Just now, luckylager said:

We do?

Yeah, I'm referring to Max

[DaBackpack]

3 minutes ago, iambrad said:

did they know though? he voted within the last 5 minutes of eod. that's pretty hard to predict 

that's the point. they didn't. 

 

if you take you guys's zfetch take to its logical conclusion, then every single person on the Max Brown wagon MUST BE TOWN, which might be the case, but I can point you to plenty of other games where the same exact thing happens but wolves end up on a wolf wagon.

[KZA]

1 minute ago, Naslund said:

Here @KZA click the post youll see why i didnt like him at first

Then I got distracted by lewi and now we're here

Hmm thank you 

[Blue Jay 22]

2 minutes ago, DumbassTurtle said:

2(Qwags) Zfetch, TimeLord 
4(ZFetch) Qwags, LuckyLager, DaBackpack, Kza
3(SnakeDoctor) MacDougal, Alison, DumbassTurtle,  
5(DaBackpack) Dallsbeep, FunnyGurl, iambrad, DankMemes187, Blue Jay
2(Naslund) Porscha 
1(Dankmemes187) Naslund

 

might need double checking

Good wagons

[Blue Jay 22]

I don’t know

[Funnygurl555]

regardless, why are we going after anyone on that wagon anyway??? we've only lynched one wolf so far? 

i know i'm biased because i was on that wagon but i'd be saying this regardless.

[KZA]

I could see Z and NIK team...but one actor at a time 

 

Of course this goes out the window if DPB goes over and flips red

[Naslund]

Unvote vote the monkey

Maybe 1/3 of my r.1 dirt list was right.

[Naslund]

Unvote vote monkey